Throughout my mid-20s, I noticed my elderly relative through the glass of a coffee shop. I felt astonished – she had departed the year before. I gazed for a brief period, then reminded myself it couldn't be her.
I'd encountered analogous situations throughout my life. From time to time, I "identified" an individual I didn't know. Sometimes I could rapidly determine who the unknown individual resembled – such as my elderly relative. On other occasions, a visage simply had a vague familiarity I couldn't recognize.
Lately, I started wondering if other people have these unusual experiences. When I inquired my companions, one said she frequently sees individuals in unexpected places who look recognizable. Others occasionally confuse a unknown person or famous person for someone they know in actual life. But some mentioned nothing of the kind – they could easily recognize people they'd met and people they hadn't.
I felt fascinated by this range of responses. Was it just yearning that made me see my elderly relative that day – or some kind of cognitive error? Studies has found we spend about 14 minutes of every hour looking at faces – do we just have inaccuracies sometimes? I was starting to understand that we can all see the same face but not experience the same thing.
Investigators have created many assessments to quantify the capacity to remember faces. There exists a broad spectrum: at one side are exceptional facial identifiers, who remember faces they have seen only for a short time or a long time ago; at the other are people with facial agnosia, who often have difficulty to identify relatives, intimate companions and even themselves.
Some tests also measure how skilled someone is at telling if they have not seen a face before. This is where I suspect I fall short. But experts "just haven't dug into this" as much as they've studied the skill to remember a face, according to brain researchers. It does seem that the two abilities use separate brain processes; for instance, there is indication that superior face rememberers and prosopagnosics do about as well as each other at identifying new faces, despite their vastly dissimilar abilities to recall old faces.
I felt curious whether these tests would offer understanding on why strangers look known. Was I someone who constantly recalls a face? I often remember people more than they recall me, and feel disappointed – a sentiment that experts say is common for superior face rememberers. But maybe I hyper-recognize faces – to the extent that even some new faces look recognizable.
I received several facial recognition tests. I worked through them, feeling puzzled at times. In one, called the memory for faces evaluation, I had to look at grayscale photos of a face from three angles, then find it in groups. During another test that directed me to pick out public figures from a mix of photos, many of the faces felt at least recognizable, but I couldn't precisely recognize them – similar to my everyday experience.
I felt doubtful about my results. But after assessment of my results, I had properly distinguished 96% of the famous person faces. The conclusion was that I qualified as a "near-exceptional facial identifier".
I also performed well in the previously seen/unfamiliar faces task, which was described as notably useful for assessing someone's recall for faces. The participant looks at a collection of 60 monochrome photos, each of a separate face. Then they examine a string of 120 comparable photos – the first group plus 60 unfamiliar countenances – and indicate which were in the original collection. The superior face rememberer benchmark is roughly 80%; I recognized 78% of the faces I'd seen. On the other end of the continuum, people with prosopagnosia correctly guess an average of 57%.
I felt pleased with my performance, but also taken aback. I remembered many of the familiar visages, but seldom mistook a unknown visage for one that I'd seen before. My performance on this indicator, called the mistaken recognition percentage, was 18%. Normal recognizers, superior face rememberers and prosopagnosics all have a false alarm rate of about 30% on average. So why was I misidentifying a stranger's face for my elderly relative's?
It was proposed that I possibly possessed some superior face rememberer capabilities. Everyone has a inventory of the faces we know in our memory, but superior face rememberers – and likely borderline straddlers like me – have a relatively large and precise catalogue. We're also possibly to distinguish countenances – that is, attribute traits to each face, such as approachability or rudeness. Studies suggests that the later element helps people to acquire and store faces to long-term memory. While differentiating may help me recognize people, it may also trick me into seeing my grandmother in a woman who has a similar air.
In addition, it was believed I might be "an active face perceiver", meaning I pay a lot of attention to faces. Others may have more mistaken recognition moments, thinking they know someone they don't know. But because I tend to look closely at faces, I am inclined to notice the stranger who similar to my grandmother. Indeed, one acquaintance who said she doesn't make facial recognition mistakes admitted she doesn't really look at the people around her.
These tests helped me understand where I stood on the range. But I wanted to understand more about what is happening in the brain when we "recognize" strangers. Investigating further, I read about a condition called excessive facial recognition (HFF), in which unfamiliar faces appear recognizable. On the surface, this sounded like it could relate to me. But the few of recorded occurrences all took place after a medical episode such as a epileptic episode or cerebral accident, unlike the peculiarity that I've been observing my whole mature years.
Through research sites, experts have heard from about 24,000 face-blind individuals, as well as people with all kinds of person recognition challenges, including perceptual alterations, like when faces appear to be liquefying. Researchers study many of these people, using tools like the previously seen/unfamiliar faces task and the Cambridge Face Memory Test.
Experts have heard from only a small number of people with potential HFF in long durations of study.
"The frequency is quite low," one expert said of HFF. However, they theorized that there may be a continuum, with some people who think every face is recognizable, and others, like me, who only experience it a several occasions a month.
An avid skier and travel writer with over a decade of experience exploring Italian slopes and sharing insights on winter sports.